A live map of reasons and replies

Did Paul desire and strive to know Jesus-biography?

Trace the strongest lines of support, challenge each claim, and follow every response as far as the reasoning goes.

Start with an argument
03 Reasons
supporting
01 Reasons
challenging

Before you begin

Orient yourself to the question

01 Clarifying the question

Was Paul committed to knowing (and confirming his knowledge) of Gospel history—the authentic and uncorrupt story of Jesus’s life, teachings, and actions more broadly?


02 New Testament historians
  • James Dunn: “[There is] a high degree of probability that Paul must have both known and cared about the ministry of Jesus,” [The Theology of Paul the Apostle (Eerdmans, 1998), 188.]

The argument field

Follow a claim. Test its reply.

Open any reason to read its case. Linked claims take you deeper into the tree.

4 arguments at this level

For

Supports this claim

3 reasons

  1. Examples show Jesus biography Paul wanted to know

    01 Supporting reason Examples show Jesus biography Paul wanted to know Read argument

    Examples show Jesus biography Paul wanted to know.

    • …Paul aimed to know Jesus's teachings. [Forthcoming]
    • …Paul aimed to know about Jesus’ conduct. [Forthcoming]
    • …Paul aimed to know about Jesus’s death.1
    Sources and notes
    1. We know this for a few reasons:
      a) We can anticipate Paul would want to know it. (See Hengel quote in the link below on the next line.)
      b) Paul did end up knowing a lot about Jesus's death.
    Copy link

  2. Paul visited Jerusalem/Peter to know it

    02 Supporting reason Paul visited Jerusalem/Peter to know it Read argument

    Paul visited Jerusalem/Peter to know it.

    • …It's plausible: Paul received tons of Jesus biography from the Jerusalem church. [Forthcoming]
    • …In Gal 1:18, Paul says he stayed at Peter's “to get information”
    Copy link

  3. Paul had clear reason to want to know Jesus biography

    03 Supporting reason Paul had clear reason to want to know Jesus biography Read argument

    Paul had clear reason to want to know Jesus biography.

    • …Paul saw Jesus as incredibly interesting/valuable (his hero). [Forthcoming]1
    • …Paul aimed to have influence over people/churches. [Forthcoming]
      • ……Paul liked to make his points by alluding to Jesus’s life. [Forthcoming]
      • ……Paul liked to base his teachings on Jesus’s teachings. [Forthcoming]
      • ……Paul wanted be educated (and to come off as educated). [Forthcoming]
    • …Paul desired to bequeth self-defining Jesus traditions on new churches. [Forthcoming]2
    Sources and notes
    1. This is relevant because, in general, people (including ancients) were interesting in knowing about their heroes.

    James Dunn: “And we can also speak without exaggeration of a universal curiosity regarding the prominent or hero figure, which is as evident in ancient writings as it is today” (Note, e.g., the degree of biographical interest evident in Dio Chrysostom in the lite and teaching of Diogenes, or, on the Jewish side, in Jeremiah preserved (by his disciples) in "The Words of Jeremiah" (Jer. I.I. i.e., canonical Jeremiah).)

    1. For example, see 1 Thes 4.1; 2 Thes 3:6; 1 Cor 11:2; 15:3; Col 2:6. These all use the words denoting the transmission and reception of tradition (paradidomi and pandambaiw). [The Theology of Paul the Apostle (Eerdmans, 1998), 186 fn13.]
    Copy link

Against

Challenges this claim

1 reason

  1. 2 Cor 5:16: Paul says we know Jesus “according to flesh” no longer

    01 Challenging reason 2 Cor 5:16: Paul says we know Jesus “according to flesh” no longer Read argument · 1 path deeper

    [See this argument and response here]

    Copy link