A live map of reasons and replies

Is it FALSE that early Christians venerated Jesus' gravesite?

Trace the strongest lines of support, challenge each claim, and follow every response as far as the reasoning goes.

Start with an argument
01 Reasons
supporting
00 Reasons
challenging

Before you begin

Orient yourself to the question

01 Our question

Is it false that early Christians around AD 30-70 venerated the tomb Jesus was buried in. Is it false that they religiously visited it and/or took special care of it?

This question impinges on larger questions, notably:

The argument field

Follow a claim. Test its reply.

Open any reason to read its case. Linked claims take you deeper into the tree.

1 arguments at this level

For

Supports this claim

1 reason

  1. There is no evidence of tomb-veneration

    01 Supporting reason There is no evidence of tomb-veneration Read argument

    No record/evidence exists for a Jesus-grave being venerated in the 1st century.1 This is relevant because “Had such been the practice of the first Christians [for Jesus's tomb], with all the significance which the very practice itself presupposes, it is hard to believe that our records of Jerusalem Christianity and of Christian visits thereto would not have mentioned or alluded to it in some way or at some point.” [James Dunn,_ Jesus: The Evidence_ (Westminster, 1985), 67.]

    Normally, for prominent ancient figures of this kind, we have such references to their tomb, and with respect to Jesus we especially have an abundance of early Christian information in which we would have expected references to turn up, if such a tomb were in fact venerated.2

    Sources and notes

    1. • Byron McCane (Religion professor at Wofford): “…the earliest hints of Christian veneration of Jesus' tomb do not surface until the early fourth century CE. (Eusebius, Vita Constantini 3.25-32.)” [“Where No one Had Been Laid”, in The Historical Jesus, Vol 3, ed. Evans (Routledge, 2004), 268.]
      • James Dunn (NT professor at Durham): “The fact remains that evidence for such interest in a tomb (whether empty or undisturbed) in the earliest decades of Christianity is wholly lacking.” [Jesus Remembered (Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2003), 837.]

    2. For example, we have records/evidence for the veneration James's tomb (the brother of Jesus).

    • A.J.M. Wedderburn (NT professor at Munich): “Although cultic veneration of hero's graves was well-attested in the Graeco-Roman world, we never read of any Christian veneration of that of Jesus. In contrast, that of his brother James was well-known, even if it was not a place of worship: around 180 CE Hegesippus records that James the Righteous had been buried near the Temple in Jerusalem and that his gravestone was still there.” [Beyond Resurrection (Hendrickson, 1999), 63.]

    Copy link

Against

Challenges this claim

0 reasons